I was given two opportunities recently to facilitate sessions focused on the design of learning environments. At KMWorld I lead a small workshop on the design of learning systems. A few weeks later I lead a professional development session for an industry analysis start-up. Although the client industries varied greatly, from aerospace to pharmaceuticals to industry analysis, the process yielded some common lessons learned.
Here is the premise: managers, and the businesses they work for, spend little time designing work experiences like on-boarding, meetings, learning, innovation, expense reporting or the annual review process. This doesn’t imply that thought doesn’t go into these experiences, but that thinking of these processes as experiences that require design is uncommon. In most cases, output trumps outcome. Most organizations need to move from the perception of work as ripples in a general flow to creating a context of discrete experiences that can be designed to achieve the mutual aims of the individual and the organization..
A question of balance
To begin, I asked participants to explore what experience they balance for in their current approach to learning: the concepts, tasks, chores, expectations and other elements that nudge and tug as one is trying to, in this case, learn. It was very interesting that the two groups took a very different approaches to answering this question. The workshop group adopted a very strategic view. They looked at the goals of the organization that could be considered co-equal to learning. These included:
- The organization’s mission
- Compliance
- Improving efficiency, increasing speed and eliminating duplication
- Knowledge transfer and knowledge retention
- Quality
- Donor expectations
- Transparency of status and process
- In contrast, the analyst’s lists presumed learning and looked at the obstacles to knowledge transfer. In other words, they believed learning took place all the time, but they had to account for conflicting demands on their time that often precluded the codification and exchange of knowledge. Here is their list:
- Original Research
- Team-based Research
- Consulting
- Revenue Generation
- Writing
- Customer Contact
- Events
- Management
- Communications
What is clear from both lists is that learning, although perhaps assumed by the analysts, was not explicitly designed into their work experience. Even where knowledge management investments existed, the design was much more industrial than holistic. Both teams focused on specific knowledge transfer deemed critical to the business at the tactical level, not on knowledge transfer for individual improvement, to capacity building, except where the tactical and the strategic might serve each other.
The industry analysts presumed learning was something core to their mission, but the other organizations saw it as one priority among many required to meet mission fulfillment goals. This is a critical observation on experience context because each experience must align with the organizations goals and objectives or it will fail to be implemented. The design must reflect the organization. This question of balance is designed to elicit responses that may require strategic review. Some of the workshop participates shared that learning was indeed auxiliary to the core mission, a nice to have, not a must have. In the industry analyst world, learning is a given, but as with most work, the question was about prioritization. Both groups suggested the list was more extensive and varied than expected, and that it helped to better frame their internal learning struggles. Like many activities in learning, there is value in naming and confronting an idea, rather than assuming it exists and will eventually be handled through some opaque process. It is important for individuals and organizations to confront their assumptions.
So for both groups, the design of a learning experience begins with the recognition of learning, its obstacles, its enablers and its alignment with other goals. Without this first step, executing the design is unlikely to result in success except at the most rudimentary level.
Proportion through Variety and Emphasis
The next phase of the process requires a deep examination of the experience to understand how people engage, what they need to keep them involved, and what the organization needs to do to communicate priorities. Variety is used to ensure that the needs of the experience constituencies are meet, and emphasis is use to identify what is important at the moment. Experiences are not static. Emphasis, should seek to bring the important task of the moment to the forefront.
Take for example, coding metadata. The KMWorld workshop created a hypothetical experience in which a worker places documents into a system, and tags the documents. I played a visual thinker who found this boring. I said I didn’t like the experience, nor did I do a good job of tagging because I was easily bored. Rather than the most effective tags for the work, I picked the minimum set and moved on.
The workshop attendees saw quickly how software design contributed to the experience. We brainstormed a bit about the creation of more visual classification software with drag-and-drop features including a more game-like experience. This approach had not been considered. Although ultimately the design of such a system depends on budget and technology constraints, the recognition and the exposition of the design helps the individual, and the organization, better understand performance gaps in individual performance because of boredom followed by expediency, or gaps in quality data generated by the bored operators.
Variety and emphasis should combine in proportions that create experiences designed to meet more than one objective. In this example, the document classifier would probably find the new experience more engaging, leading to improved quality, lower search costs and perhaps lower employee costs related to stress and turnover.
Rhythm and Motion
Experiences employ both strategic and tactical communication. Rhythm and Motion focuses on strategic communication. Most common in business is the status that says how we are doing against some date or deliverable that one or more other people care about. Strategic communication looks at movement toward a goal, thus the use of rhythm and motion. Perceptibility, or tactical communication focuses on the current deliverable or the completion of tasks, Rhythm and Motion, attempts to provide context for a sense of continuous movement toward a broad goal, such as a promotion, or a strategic goal like increasing organizational capability or capacity.
For the analyst firm, the strategic goals included more, high quality research with specific goals around customer action, such as implementation and engagement. The question on the table was:how does personal and individual learning contribute to improved research that results in improved customer engagement, and ultimately, improved margins and revenue. That is a very different question that the intuitive thought of knowledge transfer among analysts to create better analysis for the sake of analysis. This line of reasoning puts that work in to a strategic flow that results in customer engagement-and the inclusion of customer engagement means that the customer has to be part of the learning process. The firm must learn if research drives engagement, and if so, what engagement and why, so that the organization can create a positive feedback loop around that learning activity.
In the workshop we explored how to develop a quality solution to disease, conducted in a cost effective way. This lead to innovation discussions including clinical trial compliance to assure that learning was not lost through procedural error (e.g., the clinical trial was abandoned and its knowledge lost or tainted because of compliance violations) and the elimination of paper with appropriate levels of automation to identify learning opportunities and ensure compliance.
These examples give a sense of why a broad, contextual sense of Rhythm and Motion set-up an experience for success: because you can understand why you are doing something, and see your place in the context of that experience’s history.
The Tools of Work Experience Design
All work experiences include a set of tools.. These tools include: policy and practice, technology and space. Policy and practice act as the proxy for culture. During the design process, each set of tools to support a given experience is examined through the four lenses: flexibility, equitability, forgiveness and simplicity. Given space constraints, I am only going to look at one example of technology.
It was clear and intuitive that for analysts, learning is facilitated through communications technology, and through authoring tools, such as word processors that allow for reviewer feedback. At this level, each of those tools should be looked at in terms of their flexibility, equitability, forgiveness and simplicity. One experience tool that required improvement was the shared repository. The tools was not seen as flexible, it was unforgiving to novices, it was not simple to find or to use and its ability to incorporate multiple work styles (drag-and-drop, menu-driven, working from home or working locally) was either not clear or didn’t exist. This particular element of the learning experience proved a distraction to learning that tied back to balance items like communications and time to write, which were affected by the time spent trying to master this technology. More time needed to be spent redesigning this interface, or seeking other tools.
Perhaps more intriguing was the identification of the content delivery process, which is currently distant from the analyst, as a lost learning opportunity. Delivery of research is often limited to a quick transactions that brings the research to the customer (be it a credit card for downloading, subscription) This dis-integrated experience is certainly simple, but it does little to encourage learning or contribute to knowledge. Given that customer contact was something that needed to be balanced for in the learning experience, discovering when a customer has engaged in their own learning appeared to be an important cue for analysts to proactively engage customers to learning how their research affected their decision process and what questions remained to be answered. The next step would involve an employee experience design that parallels the customer experience to provide synergy in a way that is simple, flexible, equitable and forgiving.
The use of tools, be it technology or policy or space, are the only elements that can be manipulated to create the experience. The KMWorld team identified a range of policy issues from validation of data to the definition of cross-functional team roles and responsibilities. They included tools that ranged from auto-tagging to workflow, and they suggested space that challenged silos while permitting remote work. The wide variety of elements that converge on the learning experience demonstrate the value of experience design vs. process design. By using the experience as the container, organizations are forced to discover relationships that affect performance that simply aren’t visible when looking at fine-grained layers. Optimizing the content management system would never reveal a link to the customer content delivery system outside of its transactional interface, it would never reveal the lost learning opportunity analysts would gain from content consumption visibility.
Completing the Design
Design is iterative. As organizations explore their designs, they learn more about their intent and their actions. Although, like a physical design, an experience design may have a goal, the experience often exists already in some form. However, unlike a physical object you can examine or observe, the state of a work experience may be very hard to determine until name it and start deconstructing its components. Learning, in this case, about how the organization learns will inform not only the character of the learning experiences, but will help the organization determine which learning experiences it needs to design.
Both groups discovered that for learning to take place, organizations need to make it a priority, and to track results. They can certainly state that learning is important, but if they want to realize the potential of the learning available from employees, from partners and from customers, then they need to provide the right environment, and the right incentives. The only way that can happen effectively is to design them into the work experience.
Source by Daniel Rasmus